doc/nuc/usb4t-dropouts.md

usb4t: USB dropouts suspend the pool (2026-08) — RESOLVED

Outcome (2026-08-30): the disk moved off USB entirely. It now runs on direct SATA in the new host nas (nas/README.md), as pool tank, and the ks4 pull leg plus its WireGuard tunnel moved with it (ks2/nas-seed.md). Everything below is the investigation that led there — worth keeping for the diagnosis method and for the alerting gap it exposed, which applies to any host.

Symptom seen first in the nightly backup log (/var/log/incus-copy.log, job in /etc/cron.d/incus-copy): every instance fails with

Error: Refresh instance: Create instance volume from copy failed:
       Volume exists in database but not on storage

That message is misleading — incus is fine. The usb4t pool underneath was SUSPENDED, so the replica volumes incus has in its database had no storage behind them.

Diagnosis (2026-08-28)

The disk is healthy, the USB link is not:

• smartctl -a -d sat /dev/sdc: PASSED, 0 reallocated, 0 pending, 0 offline-uncorrectable, 0 UDMA CRC errors, 463 power-on hours.
• dmesg: usb 4-3: USB disconnect followed by immediate re-enumeration — the enclosure drops off the bus and comes back as a new device. Bridge is JMicron 152d:0578 (the kernel already disables UAS for it and applies quirks).
• 61 USB disconnects in 30 days; pool suspensions on Aug 17 (resilver), 19, 21, 27 (×2) and 28.
• While suspended, anything touching the pool hangs — the journal shows tasks blocked for 1000+ seconds.

Blast radius each time: nuc's own replicas (usb4t/backup/nuc) stop being refreshed, /srv/media disappears from the Jellyfin containers, and — once seeded — the ks4 pull leg (usb4t/backup/ks4) would stop too. The pool holding the off-site copy of ks4 must not be the least reliable device in the setup.

Recovery

zpool clear usb4t          # device is back; ZFS resumes IO
zpool status -v usb4t      # lists files damaged by the interrupted writes
zpool scrub usb4t          # validate the whole pool

If clear hangs: zpool export usb4t && zpool import usb4t, reboot as a last resort. Datasets remount by themselves once the pool resumes.

Damage from the 2026-08-28 incident, as first reported: two pool-metadata objects (<metadata>:<0x0>, <metadata>:<0x3d>) and one media file. The scrub cleared all of it — 1.08 T verified in 2 h 29 m, 0 B repaired, 0 errors, and the error list is now No known data errors. Those entries were artefacts of the interrupted writes, not real corruption; nothing had to be restored. (One CKSUM count remains on the vdev — a single checksum ZFS fixed from its own redundant metadata copy.)

The scrub also served as a 2.5-hour soak test of the new cable: zero USB disconnects during it.

Fixes, in order

1. Cable + port — replaced 2026-08-28 with a short quality cable straight into a rear USB-3 port, no hub. It survived a 2.5 h scrub, then dropped again on 2026-08-29 16:22 (pool suspended, cleared 08-30 00:32). Cable ruled out.
2. Disable USB autosuspend — done, and ruled out: the kernel cmdline carries usb-storage.quirks=152d:0578:u (UAS disabled for this bridge) and the device sits at power/control=on. It still dropped on 2026-08-29, so neither power management nor UAS explains this.
3. Replace the enclosure — now the prime candidate. With the cable ruled out and the disk SMART-clean (0 reallocated/pending/CRC), the JMicron 152d:0578 bridge is what remains. An ASMedia-based enclosure (or a direct SATA connection) is the durable fix. ⚠️ Until this is settled, this pool is not a trustworthy home for the ks4 off-site replica leg — treat it as a gate before seeding over FTTH.

Alerting (why nobody noticed for 11 days)

zfs-zed was installed, enabled and running — but the host had no MTA, so its notifications went nowhere for 11 days. Fixed 2026-08-28; the working chain is:

zed → mail (bsd-mailx) → /usr/sbin/sendmail = msmtp → mail.lutran.fr:587 (auth, STARTTLS)

• apt install msmtp msmtp-mta bsd-mailx
• /etc/msmtprc (mode 600) holds the SMTP account — host mail.lutran.fr, port 587 (submission), user zed@lutran.fr, STARTTLS, aliases /etc/aliases.
• /etc/zfs/zed.d/zed.rc (mode 600): ZED_EMAIL_ADDR="julien@lutran.fr", ZED_EMAIL_PROG="mail", ZED_EMAIL_OPTS="-s '@SUBJECT@' @ADDRESS@", ZED_NOTIFY_VERBOSE=1 (so scrub/resilver results are mailed too, not only failures), ZED_NOTIFY_INTERVAL_SECS=3600. Original kept as zed.rc.orig. No credentials in this file — they live only in /etc/msmtprc.

Why nuc differs from ks2/ks4 (which mail via s-nail straight to port 25, and work fine): it is not the zed config, it is the source address. ks4 is the mail server's host (internal client, mynetworks); ks2 is a datacenter IP with a PTR. nuc sends from a dynamic home IP with no PTR and no SPF alignment, so the inbound MX path treats it like any stranger. Hence submission + auth here, deliberately different from the other two hosts.

Two dead ends worth remembering:

• Port 25 is the wrong port for alerts. Authentication succeeds, then rspamd rejects the message: 554 5.7.1 Spam message rejected — a short mail from a dynamic home IP with no SPF alignment scores badly on the inbound MX path. Submission (587) does not apply those rules.
• The home IP has no PTR, so postfix's reverse lookup delays the 587 greeting by several seconds. Probes with short timeouts look like a firewall block (lost connection after CONNECT, commands=0/0 in the server log) — give SMTP tests ≥30 s before concluding anything.

ZED does not report everything — hence the watchdog

The 2026-08-29 suspension produced no email, although the mail path demonstrably worked (the scrub-finish notification arrived the evening before). Two reasons:

• a suspended pool keeps its vdev marked ONLINE, so statechange-notify.sh never fires;
• the data-class events ZED did raise were muted because ZED_NOTIFY_DATA was unset (now =1).

Fixed 2026-08-30 by adding zpool-health.sh, run every 15 min from /etc/cron.d/zpool-health. It mails only on healthy <-> problem transitions, so it is silent in normal operation and cannot spam; -t sends a test. Worth deploying on ks4 too — its data pool is single-disk and has the same blind spot.

Verify:

/root/scripts/zpool-health.sh -m julien@lutran.fr -t
tail -2 /var/log/msmtp.log          # expect smtpstatus=250

End-to-end proof: with ZED_NOTIFY_VERBOSE=1, the next scrub completion arrives as a mail by itself.